SIEX 10 Competition Teaches Nonprofit New Way of Thinking
SIEX 10 Competition Teaches Nonprofit New Way of Thinkingback

The Doe Fund is no newbie in the nonprofit world. For 25 years, the organization has run very successful programs in New York City and Philadelphia helping homeless people become self-sufficient. 

Now it wants to replicate its Ready, Willing, and Able program, its successful and cost-efficient transitional housing and employment program for homeless and formerly incarcerated, throughout the United States. Skyrocketing costs of incarceration, the expense and ineffectiveness of shelters, shrinking resources, staggeringly high rates of recidivism and increasing numbers of homeless people make scaling RWA a natural for the Social Impact Exchange Business Plan competition. SIE gave competitors access to resources on growth, group training and, for the second round, a coach. I had the pleasure of coaching The Doe Fund.

Although The Doe Fund is experienced at fundraising from government agencies and foundations, and has successfully raised money for developing the social business ventures that provide work and training for its participants, Shelley Emmer, director of foundation and corporate giving, and Maura Greaney, director of development, had not developed a business-plan based proposal for bringing the entire organizational model to scale before.

“We have an idea, a vision that has worked well in two urban areas,” Emmer said. “But how do you take a package of residential and support services, visible social enterprises, partnerships with other service providers, occupational training, and career development that work here in New York to other cities?” 

To answer that question, the organization had to define the essential elements of its programs and figure out how to set up those elements in areas where resources and culture differed dramatically from those in New York city.

And, to move forward in the competition, those elements had to be incorporated into a business plan that could be replicated.

Lessons learned
Based on her experience, Emmer has some advice for those who enter the next SIE competition or one like it. Think about:

  • Staffing. It’s a time-consuming process. You may need to hire staff or divert someone from other duties to give the competition the attention it needs. Making competition deadlines is difficult if staff is spread thin.
  • Skills. Fundraising staff should work with business development staff.
  • Culture. Talk to someone early on who is familiar with the competition and what criteria are most important. The Doe Fund made it through the first round but then had to re-write its entry to include more business-plan information, such as analysis of competition. The need to rewrite used up a precious resource: time.

What they wished they’d had

  • More clarity about the criteria: What features would the entries be evaluated on and how much would each criteria count toward the final score? as in “social impact will be count for 15 points and this is what we are looking for.”
  • Earlier access to a coach who understood the criteria and could set them on the right track in the first round;
  • Feedback on their final proposal;
  • Examples of what the judges were looking for; in the future, this could be provided by posting the winning proposals from this year.

“The competition was absolutely useful,” Emmer said. “A lot of stuff we pulled together will help us as we go forward. Geri got us to think in a different way, through business lenses. She got us to present results in a more business-oriented way, to chart things, to dig deep into what we do to show the impact.”

“This kind of thinking helped us solidify the elements of our program and why we are good,” she added. “It helped to put a different lens on it.”

Although not a finalist, The Doe Fund will go forward with Ready, Willing and Able America but now it has a clearer vision and a solid business plan.

For complete coverage of the 2010 inaugural Social Impact Exchange Conference: Taking Successful Innovation to Scale, go to Ventureneer SIEX10.